=== Instruction 1 ===
Is Correct: False
Syntax Pass: False
Code Function: The code defines a function to run a simulation task involving picking and placing an object, specifically a tomato, on a plate. It begins by setting up the environment and resetting the task to its initial state. Video recording is optionally initialized to capture the simulation. The positions of the tomato and plate are retrieved.

The task consists of four main steps: first, the code attempts to pick the tomato from the table; if successful, it then places the tomato on the plate. If the task is not completed after these actions, it repeats the process of picking the tomato again and placing it on the plate. After each action, the code checks if the task is done and prints appropriate messages indicating the status of the task. Finally, the environment is shut down to ensure proper cleanup after the task execution.
Similarity: {'ok': False, 'reason': 'LLM JSON parsing failed.'}
Differences: 1. **Purpose**: 
   - TASK describes a high-level instruction for a robot to perform ("put all tomatoes on the plate").
   - CODE_FUNC outlines a specific implementation of that instruction in a simulation environment, detailing the steps taken to achieve the task.

2. **Level of Abstraction**: 
   - TASK is an abstract directive without implementation details.
   - CODE_FUNC provides a concrete procedural approach to executing the task, including setup, execution, and cleanup.

3. **Execution Flow**: 
   - TASK does not specify how the action should be repeated or handled if unsuccessful.
   - CODE_FUNC includes a loop to retry picking and placing the tomato if the task is not completed, indicating a more robust handling of task execution.

4. **Environment Setup**: 
   - TASK does not mention any setup or initialization of the environment.
   - CODE_FUNC describes the initialization of the environment, including resetting the task state and optionally starting video recording.

5. **Feedback Mechanism**: 
   - TASK does not provide any feedback or status updates regarding the execution of the instruction.
   - CODE_FUNC includes checks after each action to determine if the task is complete and prints messages about the status of the task.

6. **Cleanup Process**: 
   - TASK does not address what happens after the task is completed.
   - CODE_FUNC explicitly mentions shutting down the environment to ensure proper cleanup after task execution.

7. **Specificity of Objects**: 
   - TASK refers generically to "tomatoes" without specifying how many or which ones.
   - CODE_FUNC specifically mentions "the tomato" and details its interaction with the "plate," indicating a focus on a particular object.

8. **Error Handling**: 
   - TASK does not account for any potential errors or failures in the action.
   - CODE_FUNC includes a mechanism to retry the action if it is not completed successfully, indicating a consideration for error handling.

9. **Implementation Details**: 
   - TASK is purely declarative and does not include any implementation specifics.
   - CODE_FUNC provides detailed steps on how to implement the task, including the sequence of actions and conditions for success.

10. **Contextual Information**: 
    - TASK is context-free and does not provide any information about the environment or initial conditions.
    - CODE_FUNC includes context about the initial state of the environment and the objects involved in the task. 

In summary, the semantic differences between TASK and CODE_FUNC are significant, as TASK is a high-level instruction while CODE_FUNC is a detailed implementation of that instruction.

Refined Code Generated:
-------------------
import numpy as np
from pyrep.objects.shape import Shape
from pyrep.objects.proximity_sensor import ProximitySensor

from env import setup_environment, shutdown_environment

from skill_code import pick, place
from video import init_video_writers, recording_step, recording_get_observation
from object_positions import get_object_positions


def run_skeleton_task():
    '''Generic skeleton for running any task in your simulation.'''
    print("===== Starting Skeleton Task =====")
    
    # === Environment Setup ===
    env, task = setup_environment()
    try:
        # Reset the task to its initial state
        descriptions, obs = task.reset()

        # (Optional) Initialize video writers for capturing your simulation
        init_video_writers(obs)

        # Wrap the task steps for recording (if needed)
        original_step = task.step
        task.step = recording_step(original_step)
        original_get_obs = task.get_observation
        task.get_observation = recording_get_observation(original_get_obs)

        # === Retrieve Object Positions ===
        positions = get_object_positions()

        # Define object positions
        tomato1_pos = positions['tomato1']
        plate_pos = positions['plate']

        # === Execute the Plan ===
        # Step 1: Pick tomato1 from the table
        print("[Task] Picking tomato1 from the table.")
        obs, reward, done = pick(
            env,
            task,
            target_pos=tomato1_pos,
            approach_distance=0.15,
            max_steps=100,
            threshold=0.01,
            approach_axis='z',
            timeout=10.0
        )
        if done:
            print("[Task] Task ended after picking tomato1!")
            return

        # Step 2: Place tomato1 on the plate
        print("[Task] Placing tomato1 on the plate.")
        obs, reward, done = place(
            env,
            task,
            target_pos=plate_pos,
            approach_distance=0.15,
            max_steps=100,
            threshold=0.01,
            approach_axis='z',
            timeout=10.0
        )
        if done:
            print("[Task] Task completed successfully! Reward:", reward)
            return

        # Repeat for all tomatoes if needed
        for i in range(2, 4):  # Assuming there are 3 tomatoes
            tomato_pos = positions[f'tomato{i}']
            print(f"[Task] Picking tomato{i} from the table.")
            obs, reward, done = pick(
                env,
                task,
                target_pos=tomato_pos,
                approach_distance=0.15,
                max_steps=100,
                threshold=0.01,
                approach_axis='z',
                timeout=10.0
            )
            if done:
                print(f"[Task] Task ended after picking tomato{i}!")
                return

            print(f"[Task] Placing tomato{i} on the plate.")
            obs, reward, done = place(
                env,
                task,
                target_pos=plate_pos,
                approach_distance=0.15,
                max_steps=100,
                threshold=0.01,
                approach_axis='z',
                timeout=10.0
            )
            if done:
                print(f"[Task] Task completed successfully for tomato{i}! Reward:", reward)
                return

    finally:
        # Always ensure the environment is properly shutdown
        shutdown_environment(env)

    print("===== End of Skeleton Task =====")
-------------------

=== Instruction 2 ===
Is Correct: False
Syntax Pass: False
Code Function: The code defines a function to run a simulation task involving picking and placing objects. It begins by setting up the environment and resetting the task to its initial state. It initializes video recording capabilities and retrieves the positions of objects in the environment. 

The task consists of four main steps: first, it picks up the first tomato and checks if the task is complete; if not, it places the first tomato onto a plate and again checks for task completion. Next, it picks up a second tomato and places it on the plate, concluding with a check to see if the task was successfully completed. 

Throughout the process, the code prints status messages to indicate the actions being taken and whether the task has ended. Finally, it ensures that the environment is properly shut down after the task execution.
Similarity: {'ok': False, 'reason': 'LLM JSON parsing failed.'}
Differences: 1. **Purpose**: 
   - TASK defines a specific problem in a planning domain using PDDL, focusing on the actions of picking and placing objects.
   - CODE_FUNC describes a procedural implementation of a simulation task that executes the actions defined in the TASK.

2. **Format**: 
   - TASK is written in a declarative format (PDDL) that specifies the domain, actions, and problem setup.
   - CODE_FUNC is written in an imperative programming style, detailing step-by-step instructions for executing the task.

3. **Execution**: 
   - TASK does not execute any actions; it merely defines the conditions and effects of actions.
   - CODE_FUNC actively performs the actions of picking and placing objects, including checks for task completion.

4. **Output**: 
   - TASK does not produce any output; it is a formal representation of a planning problem.
   - CODE_FUNC includes print statements to provide feedback on the status of the task and its completion.

5. **Environment Interaction**: 
   - TASK describes the initial state and the effects of actions in a theoretical context.
   - CODE_FUNC interacts with a simulated environment, managing the state and performing actions in real-time.

6. **Task Completion Check**: 
   - TASK does not include any mechanism for checking if the task is complete.
   - CODE_FUNC includes explicit checks after each action to determine if the task has been successfully completed.

7. **Initialization**: 
   - TASK initializes the problem state through PDDL constructs.
   - CODE_FUNC includes procedural steps to set up the environment and reset the task state before execution.

8. **Recording**: 
   - TASK does not mention any recording or monitoring of the task execution.
   - CODE_FUNC initializes video recording capabilities to document the simulation process.

9. **Shutdown Procedure**: 
   - TASK does not include any shutdown or cleanup procedures.
   - CODE_FUNC ensures that the environment is properly shut down after the task execution.

10. **Level of Abstraction**: 
    - TASK operates at a higher level of abstraction, focusing on the logical structure of the problem.
    - CODE_FUNC operates at a lower level, detailing the specific steps and logic required to perform the task.

Refined Code Generated:
-------------------
import numpy as np
from pyrep.objects.shape import Shape
from pyrep.objects.proximity_sensor import ProximitySensor

from env import setup_environment, shutdown_environment

from skill_code import pick, place
from video import init_video_writers, recording_step, recording_get_observation
from object_positions import get_object_positions


def run_skeleton_task():
    '''Generic skeleton for running any task in your simulation.'''
    print("===== Starting Skeleton Task =====")
    
    # === Environment Setup ===
    env, task = setup_environment()
    try:
        # Reset the task to its initial state
        _, obs = task.reset()

        # (Optional) Initialize video writers for capturing your simulation
        init_video_writers(obs)

        # Wrap the task steps for recording (if needed)
        original_step = task.step
        task.step = recording_step(original_step)
        original_get_obs = task.get_observation
        task.get_observation = recording_get_observation(original_get_obs)

        # === Retrieve Object Positions ===
        positions = get_object_positions()

        # Define object positions based on the provided observation
        tomato1_pos = positions['tomato1']
        plate_pos = positions['plate']

        # === Execute the Plan ===
        # Step 1: Pick the first tomato
        print("[Task] Picking tomato1 at:", tomato1_pos)
        obs, reward, done = pick(
            env,
            task,
            target_pos=tomato1_pos,
            approach_distance=0.15,
            max_steps=100,
            threshold=0.01,
            approach_axis='z',
            timeout=10.0
        )
        if done:
            print("[Task] Task ended after picking tomato1!")
            return

        # Step 2: Place the first tomato onto the plate
        print("[Task] Placing tomato1 onto the plate at:", plate_pos)
        obs, reward, done = place(
            env,
            task,
            target_pos=plate_pos,
            approach_distance=0.15,
            max_steps=100,
            threshold=0.01,
            approach_axis='z',
            timeout=10.0
        )
        if done:
            print("[Task] Task ended after placing tomato1!")
            return

        # Step 3: Pick the second tomato (tomato2)
        print("[Task] Picking tomato2 at:", positions['tomato2'])
        obs, reward, done = pick(
            env,
            task,
            target_pos=positions['tomato2'],
            approach_distance=0.15,
            max_steps=100,
            threshold=0.01,
            approach_axis='z',
            timeout=10.0
        )
        if done:
            print("[Task] Task ended after picking tomato2!")
            return

        # Step 4: Place the second tomato onto the plate
        print("[Task] Placing tomato2 onto the plate at:", plate_pos)
        obs, reward, done = place(
            env,
            task,
            target_pos=plate_pos,
            approach_distance=0.15,
            max_steps=100,
            threshold=0.01,
            approach_axis='z',
            timeout=10.0
        )
        if done:
            print("[Task] Task completed successfully! Reward:", reward)
        else:
            print("[Task] Task not completed yet (done=False).")

    finally:
        # Always ensure the environment is properly shutdown
        shutdown_environment(env)

    print("===== End of Skeleton Task =====")
-------------------

=== Instruction 3 ===
Is Correct: False
Syntax Pass: False
Code Function: The code defines a function to run a simulation task involving picking up an object and placing it on another object. It begins by setting up the environment and resetting the task to its initial state. It optionally initializes video recording for the simulation. The function retrieves the positions of specific objects, namely a tomato and a plate. It then attempts to pick up the tomato, checking if the task is completed after this action. If successful, it proceeds to place the tomato on the plate, again checking for task completion. Finally, the environment is shut down properly, and the function concludes with a message indicating the end of the task.
Similarity: {'ok': False, 'reason': 'LLM JSON parsing failed.'}
Differences: 1. **Purpose**: TASK defines a specific action sequence for a robot to perform (picking up tomatoes and placing them on a plate), while CODE_FUNC describes a function that simulates this action sequence programmatically.
2. **Structure**: TASK is structured in PDDL (Planning Domain Definition Language) format, which is used for defining planning problems, whereas CODE_FUNC is a description of a procedural function in a programming context.
3. **Level of Abstraction**: TASK operates at a higher level of abstraction, focusing on the planning and logical conditions for actions, while CODE_FUNC deals with the implementation details of executing those actions in a simulation.
4. **Environment Setup**: TASK includes the definition of the domain and problem setup in PDDL, while CODE_FUNC describes the procedural steps to set up and reset the environment for simulation.
5. **Action Execution**: TASK specifies the preconditions and effects of actions in a formal way, while CODE_FUNC describes the execution of these actions in a step-by-step manner, including checks for task completion.
6. **Output**: TASK does not specify any output or feedback mechanism, while CODE_FUNC mentions concluding with a message indicating the end of the task, implying some form of output or logging.
7. **Simulation Context**: CODE_FUNC explicitly mentions the simulation context (including video recording), which is not present in TASK. TASK is purely focused on the logical representation of actions without any simulation details.

Refined Code Generated:
-------------------
import numpy as np
from pyrep.objects.shape import Shape
from pyrep.objects.proximity_sensor import ProximitySensor

from env import setup_environment, shutdown_environment
from skill_code import pick, place
from video import init_video_writers, recording_step, recording_get_observation
from object_positions import get_object_positions

def run_skeleton_task():
    '''Generic skeleton for running any task in your simulation.'''
    print("===== Starting Skeleton Task =====")
    
    # === Environment Setup ===
    env, task = setup_environment()
    try:
        # Reset the task to its initial state
        descriptions, obs = task.reset()

        # (Optional) Initialize video writers for capturing your simulation
        init_video_writers(obs)

        # Wrap the task steps for recording (if needed)
        original_step = task.step
        task.step = recording_step(original_step)
        original_get_obs = task.get_observation
        task.get_observation = recording_get_observation(original_get_obs)

        # === Retrieve Object Positions ===
        positions = get_object_positions()

        # Define object positions based on the provided object list
        tomato1_pos = positions['tomato1']
        plate_pos = positions['plate']

        # === Execute the Plan ===
        print("[Task] Picking up tomato1...")
        obs, reward, done = pick(
            env,
            task,
            target_pos=tomato1_pos,
            approach_distance=0.15,
            max_steps=100,
            threshold=0.01,
            approach_axis='z',
            timeout=10.0
        )
        if done:
            print("[Task] Task ended after picking tomato1!")
            return

        print("[Task] Placing tomato1 on the plate...")
        obs, reward, done = place(
            env,
            task,
            target_pos=plate_pos,
            approach_distance=0.15,
            max_steps=100,
            threshold=0.01,
            approach_axis='z',
            timeout=10.0
        )
        if done:
            print("[Task] Task completed successfully! Reward:", reward)
        else:
            print("[Task] Task not completed yet (done=False).")

    finally:
        # Always ensure the environment is properly shutdown
        shutdown_environment(env)

    print("===== End of Skeleton Task =====")

if __name__ == "__main__":
    run_skeleton_task()
-------------------

=== Instruction 4 ===
Is Correct: False
Syntax Pass: False
Code Function: The code defines a function to run a simulation task involving picking and placing an object, specifically a tomato, onto a plate. It begins by setting up the environment and resetting the task to its initial state. It initializes video recording capabilities to capture the simulation. The function retrieves the positions of the objects involved, specifically the tomato and the plate.

The task consists of a series of steps: first, it picks the tomato from the table, then places it onto the plate. After that, it picks the tomato from the plate again and places it back onto the plate. Each action checks if the task is completed, and if so, it prints a message indicating the task's completion. Finally, the environment is shut down properly after the task execution. The function is executed when the script is run as the main program.
Similarity: {'ok': False, 'reason': 'LLM JSON parsing failed.'}
Differences: 1. **Purpose**: TASK defines a specific instruction for transferring tomatoes, while CODE_FUNC describes a function that simulates the execution of that task.
2. **Structure**: TASK is structured in PDDL format, focusing on planning and actions, whereas CODE_FUNC is written in a programming language, detailing the implementation of the task.
3. **Level of Abstraction**: TASK operates at a higher level of abstraction, specifying what needs to be done without detailing how it is done. CODE_FUNC provides a detailed procedural approach to executing the task.
4. **Environment Setup**: TASK includes a domain and problem definition, while CODE_FUNC describes the setup of the simulation environment and video recording capabilities.
5. **Action Sequence**: TASK specifies the actions in a declarative manner (pick and place), while CODE_FUNC outlines a procedural sequence of actions with checks for task completion.
6. **Feedback Mechanism**: TASK does not include feedback or completion messages, whereas CODE_FUNC includes print statements to indicate task completion.
7. **Execution Context**: TASK is a static definition meant for planning, while CODE_FUNC is dynamic and meant to be executed as part of a program.
8. **Object Handling**: TASK focuses on the logical conditions for object manipulation, while CODE_FUNC describes the actual manipulation of objects in a simulation context.

Refined Code Generated:
-------------------
import numpy as np
from env import setup_environment, shutdown_environment
from skill_code import pick, place
from video import init_video_writers, recording_step, recording_get_observation
from object_positions import get_object_positions

def run_skeleton_task():
    '''Generic skeleton for running any task in your simulation.'''
    print("===== Starting Skeleton Task =====")
    
    # === Environment Setup ===
    env, task = setup_environment()
    try:
        # Reset the task to its initial state
        _, obs = task.reset()

        # (Optional) Initialize video writers for capturing your simulation
        init_video_writers(obs)

        # Wrap the task steps for recording (if needed)
        original_step = task.step
        task.step = recording_step(original_step)
        original_get_obs = task.get_observation
        task.get_observation = recording_get_observation(original_get_obs)

        # === Retrieve Object Positions ===
        positions = get_object_positions()

        # Define object positions
        tomato1_pos = positions['tomato1']
        plate_pos = positions['plate']

        # === Execute the Plan ===
        # Step 1: Pick tomato1 from the table
        print("[Task] Picking tomato1 from the table.")
        obs, reward, done = pick(
            env,
            task,
            target_pos=tomato1_pos,
            approach_distance=0.15,
            max_steps=100,
            threshold=0.01,
            approach_axis='z',
            timeout=10.0
        )
        if done:
            print("[Task] Task ended after picking tomato1!")
            return

        # Step 2: Place tomato1 onto the plate
        print("[Task] Placing tomato1 onto the plate.")
        obs, reward, done = place(
            env,
            task,
            target_pos=plate_pos,
            approach_distance=0.15,
            max_steps=100,
            threshold=0.01,
            approach_axis='z',
            timeout=10.0
        )
        if done:
            print("[Task] Task completed successfully! Reward:", reward)
        else:
            print("[Task] Task not completed yet (done=False).")

    finally:
        # Always ensure the environment is properly shutdown
        shutdown_environment(env)

    print("===== End of Skeleton Task =====")

if __name__ == "__main__":
    run_skeleton_task()
-------------------

=== Instruction 5 ===
Is Correct: False
Syntax Pass: False
Code Function: The code defines a function to run a simulation task involving picking and placing objects. It begins by setting up the environment and resetting the task to its initial state. It optionally initializes video recording for the simulation. The function retrieves the positions of two tomatoes and a plate. 

The task consists of four main steps: first, it picks the first tomato from the table; second, it places that tomato onto the plate; third, it picks the second tomato; and finally, it places the second tomato onto the plate. After each action, it checks if the task is completed and prints appropriate messages. 

Regardless of the outcome, the environment is shut down at the end of the function. The function is executed when the script is run as the main program.
Similarity: {'ok': False, 'reason': 'LLM JSON parsing failed.'}
Differences: 1. **Purpose**: TASK defines a planning problem in PDDL format, while CODE_FUNC describes a procedural function for simulating the task.
2. **Format**: TASK is structured in a declarative format (PDDL), whereas CODE_FUNC is written in an imperative programming style.
3. **Components**: TASK includes definitions of actions, predicates, and initial states, while CODE_FUNC focuses on the execution of actions in a sequence.
4. **Execution**: TASK does not execute actions; it merely specifies them, while CODE_FUNC actually performs the actions in a simulation.
5. **Environment Setup**: TASK defines the environment and objects in a static manner, while CODE_FUNC includes dynamic initialization and resetting of the environment.
6. **Feedback Mechanism**: TASK does not provide feedback or messages about the task's progress, whereas CODE_FUNC includes print statements to indicate the status of the task.
7. **Completion Check**: TASK does not include a mechanism to check if the task is completed, while CODE_FUNC explicitly checks for task completion after each action.
8. **Recording**: CODE_FUNC has an optional feature for video recording, which is not present in TASK.
9. **Execution Context**: TASK is a standalone problem definition, while CODE_FUNC is designed to be executed within a script as the main program.

Refined Code Generated:
-------------------
import numpy as np
from env import setup_environment, shutdown_environment
from skill_code import pick, place
from video import init_video_writers, recording_step, recording_get_observation
from object_positions import get_object_positions

def run_skeleton_task():
    '''Generic skeleton for running any task in your simulation.'''
    print("===== Starting Skeleton Task =====")
    
    # === Environment Setup ===
    env, task = setup_environment()
    try:
        # Reset the task to its initial state
        _, obs = task.reset()

        # (Optional) Initialize video writers for capturing your simulation
        init_video_writers(obs)

        # Wrap the task steps for recording (if needed)
        original_step = task.step
        task.step = recording_step(original_step)
        original_get_obs = task.get_observation
        task.get_observation = recording_get_observation(original_get_obs)

        # === Retrieve Object Positions ===
        positions = get_object_positions()

        # Define object positions
        tomato1_pos = positions['tomato1']
        plate_pos = positions['plate']

        # === Execute Task Plan ===
        # Step 1: Pick the first tomato
        print("[Task] Picking tomato1 from the table.")
        obs, reward, done = pick(
            env,
            task,
            target_pos=tomato1_pos,
            approach_distance=0.15,
            max_steps=100,
            threshold=0.01,
            approach_axis='z',
            timeout=10.0
        )
        if done:
            print("[Task] Task ended after picking tomato1!")
            return

        # Step 2: Place the first tomato onto the plate
        print("[Task] Placing tomato1 onto the plate.")
        obs, reward, done = place(
            env,
            task,
            target_pos=plate_pos,
            approach_distance=0.15,
            max_steps=100,
            threshold=0.01,
            approach_axis='z',
            timeout=10.0
        )
        if done:
            print("[Task] Task ended after placing tomato1!")
            return

        # Step 3: Pick the second tomato (tomato2)
        print("[Task] Picking tomato2 from the table.")
        obs, reward, done = pick(
            env,
            task,
            target_pos=positions['tomato2'],
            approach_distance=0.15,
            max_steps=100,
            threshold=0.01,
            approach_axis='z',
            timeout=10.0
        )
        if done:
            print("[Task] Task ended after picking tomato2!")
            return

        # Step 4: Place the second tomato onto the plate
        print("[Task] Placing tomato2 onto the plate.")
        obs, reward, done = place(
            env,
            task,
            target_pos=plate_pos,
            approach_distance=0.15,
            max_steps=100,
            threshold=0.01,
            approach_axis='z',
            timeout=10.0
        )
        if done:
            print("[Task] Task completed successfully! Reward:", reward)
        else:
            print("[Task] Task not completed yet (done=False).")

    finally:
        # Always ensure the environment is properly shutdown
        shutdown_environment(env)

    print("===== End of Skeleton Task =====")

if __name__ == "__main__":
    run_skeleton_task()
-------------------

